Monday, December 12, 2011

An Offensive System or Just Plays

I've been having this thought for a few years now, does the system make the plays or do the plays make the system?  The 'ol chicken or egg question applied to offensive theory.

When I was first given the opportunity to coordinate an offense I had a ton of ideas.  I'm not running an offense currently but I still have lots of ideas, some I like for a long time, some just sound cool in my head, some look great on the board and the best ones actually work.  If you read a lot about football, you may have seen this article from Smartfootball.com about the constraint theory for offensive football.  It's worth a read, but in summary it discusses the theory that offensive football is built on a system that has "bread and butter" plays and then builds constraint plays off of those to take advantage of a defense that is cheating in some way.

What I'm wondering is, can great plays be great in any offensive system?  Can a coach create an offense that is less dependent on a system and more dependent on simply running good plays?

When I was a high school player, we played a few wing t teams that would continuously kill us on the crossbuck/scissors play.  I even played against a team in college that did the same thing.  I always swore that if I were ever in charge of an offense I would run that play because in my experiences it was unstoppable.  Well, we did run it a few times at Dunnellon High School with great success.  We weren't a wing t team, we were actually a 21 personnel pro style team with a great tailback, and the play wasn't my play at all, it was our head coach's.  Once I got a college coordinating job, I convinced myself that the play didn't fit into our system (spread, no-huddle, zone read) and never took the time to install it.  Since I never tried to install it, I've been left with this question, would the play have worked for us or would we have needed to run a system that set up this play as a constraint play?

There comes a point in coaching where you have to decide what you're going to give your reps to in practice.  Some guys are purely repetition guys.  They believe that you have to rep something a fairly high number of times to become proficient enough at it to be consistently successful.  While I certainly agree with that sentiment to a point, there are numerous examples that coaches can point to where they repped something once or twice during practice, sometimes not even in a live scrimmage setting, and ran it once in a game for a big play.  I once listened to Dave Christenson speak when he was the OC at Mizzou and he said that during their Chase Daniel years they would put in ten new plays a week.  That's right, TEN new plays a week!  Now, with the hour restrictions that the NCAA puts on coaches, you can't tell me that Mizzou was repping those ten plays more than a handful of times during the course of a game week.  In the same talk he said that there were weeks when they only ran one or two of those plays and there were weeks when they ran all 10.  When he was asked about the limited number of reps and how he was able to feel comfortable calling the plays, he said something to the effect of "the guy getting the ball rarely screws it up, so you don't have to worry about him."  And if it worked, who am I to say it's an unsound philosophy...

If you've seen Boise State throughout the years, like I know you have, it's hard to understand exactly what they do on offense.  They've become known for trick plays, like these beauties, and a ton of pre-snap shifts and motions.  But they also score a ton of points and average a bunch of explosive plays.  I don't know what kind of system they run, I guess you could call it some kind of pro-style hybrid, but to me they epitomize an offense that is based on just running good plays.  I don't think you can fit them into a box.  They don't fit the profile of having an offensive system.  With that said, I'm certain that they have their "day one" formations and a play or two that is a staple to their playbook, but they aren't a classic zone-read team or a two back power team or an option team or whatever labels exist out there.  They sort of grab bag plays, use their imagination and work to their strengths.  It's obviously worked for them.

In reality, Boise State is the exception.  Most offenses that have been great throughout college football have had a concept or two that defines them.  The Mike Leach, Hal Mumme air raid guys are super simple in formations.  They use a right handed formation virtually every snap and rep a handful of plays until they are so good at running Mesh, Shallow Cross and Verticals that they become almost unstoppable.  Urban's spread option attack utilizes creative formations to accomplish the plus one advantage (meaning the offense has one more guy than the defense in a given set, usually the QB).  The Pro-style offense was pretty potent for teams like USC, Ohio State and Michigan (before the Rich Rod era).  Speaking of Rich Rod, his three zone run game combined with the bubble option has created so many disciples that it is now impossible to watch college football without seeing a number of teams running some form of the spread offense.

So there in lies the question, could a coach put together an offense with the best plays from every offensive system and run them as an offense?  Could you run the Power I triple option of the Nebraska teams on one play and then run the Air Raid Mesh on the next?  Maybe, but then again, maybe not.  How about combining the quick passing and formations of the West Coast offense with the 11 or 21 personnel running game of Power, Counter and Trap.  Alex Gibbs will tell you that the Outside Zone isn't a part of your run game, it is your run game and if you're looking to add it to your repertoire as a compliment, it won't work (although coach Gibbs is certainly more colorful and assertive that I just was about that point).  There are a bunch of great plays out there, some have stood the test of time, others have come and gone but at one point or another a coach has had success with just about every form of offensive football.  I think the conclusion that I've come to is this:

Everything is a constraint for something else.  If you're a zone-read guy and you can't block the overhang, handle him with the bubble.  If you're a 4-verts team and you can't get completions vs. 2 high safeties, teach your seam readers to sight adjust their routes.  If you're a wing t guy and the buck sweep is getting stuffed, slip in the cross buck and hammer the over aggressive linebackers with some misdirection.  If you're a Power team and that backside LB is shooting gaps before you can get him cut off, run the counter back at him.  But if you don't want to be known as a (fill in the blank here) guy, get your players to become really comfortable with formations and motions and then figure out which plays give you the best match-ups that week.  The one thing I've found is this, players on good teams seem to rise to the level of expectations that are set for them.  If you constantly harp on repetitions, your players will feel like they need a ton of reps to become good at something.  If you expect them to be able to handle changes, big and small, and you preach the importance of being adaptable, it's amazing how adaptable they will become.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

The Future of Offensive Football

Speaking exclusively to college football here.

The National Championship game that featured Auburn vs Oregon was the culmination of the spread phenomenon in offensive football.  Both teams operated at a ridiculously high tempo and the game was exceptionally fun to watch.  Not for nothing, but if we think college coaches are paid right now, wait until there is no NFL season next year and watch how popular college ball gets, then these guys are REALLY going to get paid!   But I digress.

The progression of the college football offense has been a relatively hot button issue in the last few years.  Traditionally, progressions have begun with offensive guys tinkering and refining ideas that seem innovative and new and defensive guys working through the problems and finding ways to defend it all.  For the purposes of this article I'm going to loosely define the rise of the spread as beginning with the Woody Dantzler quarterbacked/Rich Rod OC'd teams at Clemson from '98-'00.  I realize that spread football began before then, but since Dantzler was the first QB to go 1,000 yards rushing and 2,000 yards passing in the same season in NCAA history, I'll credit him with the popularity of the QB run game that has truly defined the modern day spread philosophies.  Dantzler changed the way coordinators viewed the QB.  Guys began to step back and realize the value of plus one football.

In a sense, every coach is looking for that plus one in football.  Defensive coordinators are looking to get their unblocked guy into the same area as the ball carrier and OC's are looking to create a surface where they have a hat for a hat and their +1 becomes the ball carrier.  Now it's important to recognize that having a QB who is a legitimate running threat is nothing new to the game of football.  However, the way that QB's are being used in today's college game is a bit different from the past.  Working on the +1 premise, the best way to create favorable match-ups for your offensive team is by creating formations that stress the defense.  In order to do this, your QB has to be a viable threat to throw the football down the field.  If you can get a guy in the mold of a Woody Dantzler, you all of a sudden start to see that defenses have to play two high safeties vs four receivers.  In addition, when you spread 4 receivers across the field, most defenses will walk an outside linebacker to honor the #2 receivers (or, even better, replace the OLB with a smaller DB type).  Once all of this happens, a play caller can't help but look at the box and see he has 5 offensive lineman, a running back and a QB and the defense has four defensive lineman and 2 linebackers.  Any way you count it, that's 7 on 6 in the offense's favor meaning that if you run the QB, you can block the entire box and still have a ball carrier.  It's not quite that simple, but you get the idea.

Having watched a bunch of football this past season, I realized that there are more teams running some form of the spread offense than not.  It's almost a badge of courage at clinics, you've got your spread guys and your traditional (read old school) guys.  When I sat down and watched all of the BCS games, I came away with a new take on the future of college football and where I think the progression of offensive football will go.  If we take a look at the 10 teams that played in the BCS, here's how it breaks down:

Auburn - Spread
Oregon - Spread
Stanford - Pro
Va. Tech - Pro (with some spread elements)
Ohio State - Pro
Arkansas - Spread
Oklahoma - Spread (with some pro elements)
UConn - Didn't belong, but Pro (I guess)
TCU - Spread
Wisconsin - Pro

Now I realize that there are more nuances and subtle differences amongst everybody and that it's not really fair to group everyone into either a Pro style or a Spread style of offense, but it's sort of semantics for the sake of this piece.

Everyone's got their own coaching style and their own beliefs and systems.  You can look at a team, find out what their #1 run play is and discern a lot.  Is it Zone, Power or some form of Option?  Once you know that, it's not that difficult to figure out the rest.  Most good offenses run a little bit of all three, but there will inevitably to one scheme that is preferred over the other two.  I think it's sort of easy to sit back and say, "Well, defenses keep putting smaller and smaller defenders out there so offenses are eventually going to get into 21 personnel and just out-physical people."  I'd say that accounts for about 20% of my theory.  It's not insignificant, but it's far from the top of the list.

It used to be that teams would turn to the option and the spread as ways of leveling the playing field.  Meaning teams with inferior talent would run these systems as a way to level the competitive edge.  As more and more teams and coaches started seeing the value of the spread, more and more teams began running it.  Now, there is virtually no competitive edge to be gained through the spread because everyone is running it.  Instead, a team like Stanford which historically has lesser talent has been able to rise to a level of prominence through a consistent, pro-style offensive approach.  The number one reason they had the season they did wears #12 and touches the ball on every play.  Anyone who's coached a single down of football in their life will tell you that the QB is the most important position on the field.  It's vitally important to have the same guy taking snaps week 12 or 13 that was taking snaps during pre-season camp.  To that end, implementing schemes that provide flexibility in protection and a heavy emphasis on a running game that doesn't involve the QB as a staple is going to be the new trend.

There will never, and I feel comfortable here saying never, be a return to the 21 and 22 personnel days of the past where 20 of the 22 players on the field were aligned between the hash marks.  The benefits of getting athletes in space and spreading out defenses to use the whole field are undeniable and will forever have a place in the game.  You will, however, start to see more and more teams adopting the Stanford, Wisconsin, Boise State, USC approach to offensive football.  You'll start to see coaches who grew up in the spread transitioning to a more traditional offensive model.  One that doesn't require your QB to run 15 times a game, one that has some better flexibility with protections and one that will (in the short term at least) allow the offense to take advantage of battling smaller, quicker athletes that are populating defenses right now.  These coaches who grew up in the spread will begin to cherry pick all of the best attributes of the spread, the ability to change tempos, the ability to create match-ups, the +1 run game count, etc., and build them into an offensive system that allows their QB to stay upright and healthy.  With teams like Boise State and Wisconsin scoring points the way they have been and a team like Stanford rising up from the doldrums of college football, this phenomenon will catch on.

Understand that this change will be subtle and reasonably slow, evolution takes time, but it will happen.  The fad that is the spread is starting to lose some of its luster and coaches are starting to realize that you can have spread elements to your system without being a "spread guy."  Need proof?  Take a look at all the teams, college and pro, running some variation of "The Wildcat."  You think those teams aren't realizing the benefits of +1 football?  That won't go away, teams and coaches will continually look for ways to maximize their advantage.  What I predict will happen is more and more coaches will begin to create, refine and implement offensive systems that employ the best elements of the 21 personnel pro-style attack and the 10 personnel spread attack.  It's all about the packaging of terms and teaching progressions in your offense.  The guys who will have the most success will be the dynamic teachers who are able to easily teach multiple concepts to groups of young men with limited time and resources.  It still comes down to the old saying: it's not what you know, it's what your players know!

Let me know what you think, I'd love to hear from you...